Sunday, 11 December 2016

Proofs And How to Show Them

In university proofs is one of the more common ways of showing mathematical concepts, showing how they work, why they are true, and why they work and can be used in other mathematical proofs. Learning to prove mathematical concepts is then useful to learn during high school as it can provide a needed challenge for students who want a harder challenge or possibly spark an interest in math for some students by showing them why the theorem is true.

On Wednesday we observed two ways of doing proofs, one through deductive reasoning and another using an app to demonstrate to students that something is true. The deductive approach is a more traditional approach to solving proofs in which the theorem is proven by working through it logically and using other theorems to help prove the theorem for every possible case. While this approach is very interesting to see and can be very convincing if explained properly it is a very abstract approach as well. Since the aim is to prove the theorem for every single case variables are used instead of numbers which could get very confusing for some people. As such doing proofs through deduction could prove the theorem to yourself but it could be difficult to prove it to a friend or skeptic, especially if either of them aren't used to seeing math in more abstract terms. Another way we investigated for solving proofs is by using an application called "Geogebra". This can easily show that a theorem works (example all angles in a right triangle equals to 180 degrees) by showing examples in which the theorem is true. However it may convince a sceptic or a friend, as they get to see the theorem being applied and working, it may not convince yourself as there could be cases in which the theorem may not work. So individually both methods to proving something may not convince a student, depending on how engaged they are with learning about mathematics, but combining the two can probably convince more students then if done separately. Showing the students examples of the theorem working before explaining the proof of the theorem allows students to see how it works as well as why it works.

1 comment:

  1. Thanks! I like your analysis and suggested mixed approach (and in fact, that is how I taught these circle geometries, using a combination of the two kinds of proof or demonstration). I must say though that the students were far more engaged in the hands-on Geogebra than they were with me explaining the deductive proofs!

    ReplyDelete