Monday, 26 September 2016

Celtic Knots


For the math art project my group focused on making Celtic knots and how they relate to mathematical topics found in the secondary school curriculum. Above is a board without the borders on it that is needed to make the Celtic knots. The set of rules that we used in order to construct the knots were from a paper from the University of Edinburgh. We can use Celtic knots as an example of the different types of symmetry that exist in everyday objects, or as a basis for logical thinking. I found that when I started to get used to setting up proper borders and using the proper tiles I simply got used to looking at where the bends should logically go according to where the borders are placed. I didn't have to rely on the initial rules that we had read about and just simply had to look at where the tiles could logically be placed at to complete the knots. 

Using real example of Celtic knots can probably help students understand better how objects in the third-dimension can be projected onto a two-dimensional plane. For some students it's difficult to imagine how a 3D object can be drawn or shown on a plane or how a 2D image can be presented as a real life object. Using Celtic knots students can more easily visualize how these objects can be projected on a plane which is made much easier with Celtic knots relative flatness. Using Celtic knots can also help foster interest in bigger mathematics ideas, like with topology and knot theory. Celtic knots could also be used as an example of how mathematics underlies basic ideas that are found in other scientific ideas. One of the more interesting application that I found out about knot theory was using it to better understand chirality of molecules, especially when concerning the trefoil knot. 

145px-Tricoloring.png
Chirality is basically two molecules/images that are mirror images of one another but are not superimposable with one another. Chirality is important for chemistry as it can dictate what the function of the molecule is and can potentially make it harmless or dangerous. 

For more information about the Celtic knots and knot theory here are the slides of the presentation. A reference for the rules needed to set up border for Celtic knots and how to place the tiles can be found here.

Friday, 23 September 2016

Chessboard Puzzle


How many different squares of all sizes do you think you can fine on an 8x8 chessboard? I was able to find 204 unique squares. I was able to find out by first initially counting how many 1x1 squares there was which was equal to 64 different squares. The number of individual unique 2x2 squares that appear on the board was 49. The number of individual unique squares that I was able to find are shown in the bottom:

1x1
64
2x2
49
3x3
36
4x4
25
5x5
16
6x6
9
7x7
4
8x8
1

Adding all the numbers up will give us a total number of uniques squares of 204. There was two unique  but similar ways to solve this question. You could count the number of squares you found on the row by the number of squares you counted however after a while you start noticing a pattern that starts to appear by counting the squares. More specifically you start to notice that the total numbers of squares is equal to the sum of all squares of all numbers up to 8. 

64+49+36+25+16+9+4+1 = 82+72+62+52+42+32+22+12 = 204

When applied to a classroom I would try to have students start off with a smaller square like a 4x4 size square before moving up to the 8x8 square puzzle that was shown above. After solving the 8x8 square puzzle I would try to bump it up to something larger like a 10x10 square. If some students needed a more difficult challenge then I would start asking them what would happen if they had a chessboard with an infinite number of squares in the row and column to see if they did understand the pattern that they were observing. 

Tuesday, 20 September 2016

Learning How You Teach


The above graph is from a self-test that was made in order for teachers, or anyone whose job entails educating others, to learn what their teaching perspective are. There are five different teaching perspective that can help make you understand what you consider to be needed to be an effective teacher. The five perspectives are Transmission, Apprenticeship, Developmental, Nurturing, and Social Reform. All five perspectives are broken down to three subsection which are what your beliefs on teaching/learning are, your intention when you're teaching, and what are your actions when teaching. Details of he five perspective can be seen on the main site.

From the above graphs it initially seems that I put a higher preference in developmental and nurturing the students when teaching. In other words I believe that students learn better by asking difficult questions that can reasonably answer with a bit of effort, and thinking back on their previous knowledge, and that they can learn better with a bit of encouragement from me and not pushing them into getting the correct answer. This seems like what I was trying to aim for when I was teaching first year chemistry lab last year but what surprised me the most was how low transmission scored, especially in the beliefs and intention columns of the perspective. Specifically that it doesn't seem that I believe that being an effective teacher means that I have to be an expert at the subject nor do I intend to do that when I to do that. However it seems like I act as an expert in the subject as my action column is about as high as three of the other perspectives.

Alternatively the individual columns for social reform teaching perspective suggests that while I believe an effective teacher is to teach students to eventually think more critically of what they are reading, I don't actually act on it when I am teaching. I wonder if this has to do with me trying to be a science/mathematics teacher, with both subject areas emphasizing on accepting the text as truth or as a fact. I wonder if there is a way to change this or think more critically about when teaching, as even science students need to think critically of science papers and textbook. 

Sunday, 18 September 2016

Puzzles and Learning


A few days ago we were given this puzzle to think over, not just because it looks like a fun puzzle to do (it was) but because it requires us to think how we solved this puzzle and what we could teach with this. That last point might not seem to be all that important but modst of the time I don't think about what I'm doing to solve a problem beyond what number do I have to use. This is probably a result of me relying mostly on instrumental mathematics to get by high school math and it eventually becoming a habit for me. So this is as good time to write down my thought process through all this.

2
3
4
24
5
1
8
40
6
7
9
378
60
21
288

Solving puzzle one I tried to eliminate the first column/row that stuck out to me, which in this case was column 2 with the numbers coming out to 21, an odd number. Solving this number first helps eliminate a lot of possible numbers since there is only a few numbers that can produce the number 21, specifically 3 and 7. Knowing that then there's only one other number that can be placed along 3 and 7 in the column which would be 1. As for which rows those numbers can be placed the simplest way I though of was dividing the row product with one of the three numbers that I had chosen. Since 24 and 40 was not divisible by 7, 3 was placed in the first row and 7 on the bottom with 1 being placed in the middle row. Similar methodology was used for the other numbers on the other columns/rows, except that any combination that included a number that was already used for the second column was eliminated and not considered. For example the possible combination to make 60 that I thought of was 2,5,6 or 3,4,5. But since 3 was already used I eliminated the second possibility and continued on. The third column is much easier since there was only a few numbers that could divide 288 into a reasonable size number without having to repeat a single number. For example while 288 can be made with 6,6,8 it would be breaking one of the rules of the puzzle. As such 4,8,9 was the set of numbers that I found worked best. 

4
1
7
28
1
4
7
28
2
8
9
144
8
6
3
144
5
6
3
90
5
2
9
90
40
48
x=189

40
48
x=189


The second puzzle that was given was a bit trickier due to one number being unknown (x) to us, with us having to solve it at some point when solving the puzzle. I employed the same methodology that I used before by starting with the number 28 due to it being the smallest number on the puzzle. From then on I slowly solved the puzzle by looking at the possible combinations of numbers whose products can give me one of the numbers on the rows since all the numbers there are known. Deciding which column those numbers where placed was similar to how it was done in the first puzzle. When I was done I got x = 189, and the answer to the left. However when I looked at the answer I noticed that 4 could divide both 40 and 48 to an obtainable number of 10 and 12 respectively.

There are a couple lessons that you can help teach students by doing this puzzle. One of them obviously being a refresher on how to do multiplication and division but another important one would be demonstrating to students how important order is when solving a math problem and can be used as an introduction to doing algebra or if they're starting to learn about the order of operations. This puzzle is also a good example of how you can get an answer by doing it much differently than others and how there is no one right way of doing math. The second puzzle demonstates this nicely as the unknown number of 189 can be found in two different ways. I'm sure there are more ways to answer the second puzzle so I'm curious to see if anyone else got a different answer as well.

Tuesday, 13 September 2016

Richard Skemp and The Difficulties of Instrumental and Relational Mathematics

Immediately when Richard Skemp begins to define what instrumental and relational understanding is I started questioning how I learned things chemistry, especially when it comes to using mathematics (usually algebra and basic arithmetic). Looking back on my last five years in chemistry most of the math work that was done was just following a set series of rules and path that we all learned in high school. That was the extent of math that my fellow chemistry undergraduates and I really cared about when looking for the concentration of a chemical, or the mass of an empty beaker. This was a huge detriment to us when we really had to think harder when given a formula to use for a physical chemistry problem. None of us really understood what the formulas meant or how to use them or which number in our data table we should be using. This usually resulted in long weekly line ups in which our professor would describe it using terms we would understand but this would result in more confusion then answers.

This may seem like rambling but I think it's an example of the mismatch between instrumental and relational mathematics that Richard Skemp highlighted in the article, and highlights how this mismatch can extend far beyond mathematics. We all wanted a set series of instructions and rules of which numbers do we need to use for this formula while our professor tried to convey the answer to us by making us think a little more. And our confusion of why there wasn't a set series of rules made us dislike physical chemistry despite the underlying understanding that physical chemistry explains why all of our chemical reactions work. But I do wonder how much better we would have been at answering these questions if we had spent more time in the office looking for an explanation rather then a series of rules. Maybe its something we as teacher candidates for mathematics and/or other subjects can look into answering in the course and during our practicum.

The article brought up an interesting example when Richard Skemp went to ask a colleague of his on why his students wrote their answers in a specific way, only for the colleague to tell his students to write the answer as shown in the textbook. I found this part humorous but it got me to think about why I was taught to answer written mathematical questions in the form of a sentence, or why showing the work on how you got the answer when answering a question. Shouldn't it be enough that the student got the answer or am I maybe missing another reason why we were taught to do it like that. I would think that showing the students work would only lead to more rules in which the students assume is the "correct" way of doing it rather than thinking of alternatives means to answering the questions.

When we start out practicum, even if it isn't mathematics, it should be important for us to try to convey to the students why relational understanding/mathematics is just as important as instrumental understanding/mathematics. Richard Skemp takes a balanced approach in understanding both side of thinking without putting them in direct opposition as one another which I like and enjoy, especially when listing off the benefits of relational mathematics he starts with the number 4 rather than starting over with 1. Because at the end of the day we're all teaching a group of 30+ students who all learn differently and are in the course because it is a requirement for them rather than a passion. I don't think one method is better than the other, they both have their benefits and issues, but I do think we can be better educator if we use both tools to our advantage.


Monday, 12 September 2016

Welcome!

Welcome to my blog! I hope you have a fun time here and join me on this interesting journey learning all the in and out of secondary mathematics!