Wednesday, 21 June 2017

Why A Blog?

This blogs contains, more or less, my perspective on what I should try to do as a teacher at the very start of the education program. It contained my thoughts on how we could integrate social justice issues into math, different ideas as to teach students, what materials we can use in the classroom, and my own brief reflections on what activities and puzzles I can give to my students. This blog was made for EDCP 342A, the math pedagogy class, so a lot of the older posts are about teaching math and how to teach math. However I feel that this blogs gives me a good snapshot of what I was when I first started here, with the new blog post being a reflection of who I currently am as a teacher.

If you want to see a more complete evolution of my change as a teacher, from how I set up lesson plans and to how I developed my tests, I will include a link to my Google Drive folder containing all of my lesson plans that I currently have. Feel free to take a look at them and use them in the future if you want or make your own interpretation of how I've changed since September.

Google Drive

Why Teaching?

That questions gets asked a lot, especially during this program. And it's an important one to ask too. Why we teach something can reflect on how we'll teach, what we teach, how we will interact with our colleagues and students, how long we can be teachers, and where we'll end up in the future. So that makes the question "why do you want to teach?" a loaded questions to ask. For example if someone where to answer that they were teaching only for the money then that would tell someone that probably wouldn't stay around as a teacher for long, they could teach in a very bland and dry style, wouldn't attempt to help students or work with their colleagues, and would move on to another career in the immediate future. 

So why do I want to teach? For me that's a question that's difficult to answer because it's hard to pinpoint on exact reason as to why I wanted to get into teaching. I knew that I wanted to teach since my second year of my undergraduate but I didn't really had an explanation as to why. Even when I started teaching as a teaching assistant in the last year of my undergrad I still didn't have a concrete answer to that question other than I enjoy teaching others. 

So then the next question I should ask myself is what is it about teaching that I enjoy so much? That's a tougher question for me to answer because when I'm enjoying something I tend to not think about why I'm enjoying it. It's a weird statement just for the fact that I'm basically saying that when I teach I'm not thinking much, but it's more like I enter a comfortable groove or mindset where I can comfortably and confidently do what I need to do as a teacher. I think I wouldn't be able to get to that point if I didn't enjoy the planning process as well. To me planning a unit or a lesson is like solving a puzzle. In order to make a good lesson I need to take into consideration how long my lecture will be, what kind of activity will I get the students, how long the students will take, what to do after the lesson is done, what kind of problems or questions the students might bring up, what possible disruption might occur during class, as well as consider how all these things might fit and react with each other. Another thing that I enjoy about teaching is that I'm constantly learning new. Whether it's something a student has learned recently, or something interesting that I learned when planning my lesson, or even a suggestion from a colleague about how to teach a certain lesson I'm constantly interested in the learning process that comes with being a teacher. 

While it's not possible for me to like everything about teaching, the idea of talking to parents or the school administration makes me nervous at times, in general I enjoy teaching. I enjoy the process of planning out a lesson, I enjoy interacting with the students, I enjoy the learning and growing process that is needed to be a teacher, and I even enjoy the act of teaching itself. So I guess my answer to "why teaching" would simply be because I enjoy teaching. 

Things That Didn't Work

A lot of things didn't work out so well during my practicum. A lot of lessons fell flat on its face because I wasn't as prepared, confident, or comfortable with the material. So why wasn't I as prepared, confident, or comfortable as I could have been that would have made these lessons more successful? I think it was due to me not having a comfortable starting off point. This is true when I first started with chemistry and especially true when I started with teaching math.

With chemistry and I was comfortable with the idea that I was going to spend most of my time lecturing and giving students questions to help them understand the lesson and the content, with labs and quizzes to help assess them on their knowledge. So with chemistry I had a good idea of where I wanted to start with, with the problem being how was I going to get there. When it came to teaching mathematics I only had the rough idea of not having it be too traditional. With math I wanted to try different things and have students figure out the problems themselves with little help from me.

It became apparent to me during the first lesson that this was not going to work at all. I was stumbling with my words, I lacked any sort of confident when speaking and explaining the content to the students, I spoke too fast as if I wanted to just stop speaking and let students to start working, The activity itself wasn't too engaging and just resulted in the students in getting bored and not learning anything. The lessons contained multiple errors and misconceptions about the content that I immediately had to fix during the lessons, which wasted more time and caused more confusion among the students. These problem repeated themselves constantly in math up until my midpoint meeting. After my midpoint meeting I decided to stop trying to be different and try a more traditional method of teaching math. I would teach students by starting with a lecture, a short break for students to answer example questions, followed by more lecture before students went to do textbook questions or questions from a worksheet. I was also given the suggestion of using some sort of script to help me during the lecture portions.

By the time I dropped math from my workload during my wind down my math lessons resembled how I was teaching chemistry. I was giving my students lecture notes for the students to have something to look at and follow along with during the lesson, I was getting them to spend more time going through easier examples and debriefing as to what they have done in order to help them understand the material. I was giving students more time in class to work on assigned questions from the textbook. More importantly I was more confident in teaching the materials, and because I had written down the notes beforehand I was able to reduce the amount of mistakes that I was making. Having a starting point, a point in which you are comfortable in teaching was necessary for me to have a successful practicum as it gave me a point in which I can grow from.

Monday, 19 June 2017

Developing Better Tests and Quizzes

One of the biggest challenges during my practicum was writing good quiz and test questions. I didn't know if the questions that I made would actually test the students understanding of the content or if what I was writing down was just going to have the students rely on solely on how much they remember from class. In my opinion my very first test I made, a safety test for Science 8, highlights the problems I was having with making up good questions for tests. About 3/4 of the test were multiple choice and true/false questions with the last part being short answers. When making this test I found that while multiple choice questions were easy to make there were hard to make interesting or challenging. Most of the multiple choice questions required students to remember information that they learned previously. The short answer questions are slightly better but again relied on the students to recall materials that they remembered or make simple observations of a picture. If I was to write the test now I would reduce the number of multiple choice questions or even remove them entirely and include more short answer questions. I would change the short answer questions to ask students to explain their answers as I found that students wrote one word answers for the questions the first time around. In hindsight I would unknowingly implement these changes in future tests and quizzes of mine.

When developing my first math test I asked my SA how he designed his tests. He designed his test differently from all the other tests I've seen and taken as a student. He designed his test by splitting up his questions into 4 sections, C-, C+, B, and A questions. If students are able to get all the questions right for either sections then they would earn that grade. For example if students were able to get all the A level questions right then they would get an A for that test. Percentages was a subjective value that he would determine on a later date based on his observations on students. He had some flexibility when marking the test. For example if a student only got some questions right for the C- and B level questions he would give them a C+ as they demonstrated they had a solid understanding of the materials. The philosophy he used when designing questions for these types of tests was that C- questions should demonstrate that the students have a basic understanding of the material, enough for them to past the unit. C+ and B questions should be questions that are more difficult but something that they've encountered before if they had done the handout or textbook questions. A level questions were questions that they probably didn't see much of during the course but would instead require them to have a deep understanding of the content learned in the unit in order to get the questions right. For my SA test should accurately determine the students understanding of the content and that A should only be given if the student has an strong understanding of it.

I adopted this philosophy when I made the test for my statistics unit test. The first section is simple and straight forward asking students to analyze and calculate data, as well as explain why certain numbers are given based on the data set. The C+ questions followed the same idea with students doing more complicated calculations and having to go into more detail when explaining how certain calculations are done and how each part of the equations work. The B level questions bump the difficulty higher, such as asking students to calculate the standard deviation of a small data set and applying their understanding of the content to a contextual question. The A level questions are much more difficult and are questions that students wouldn't normally encounter. For example students are asked to develop their own data table based on certain conditions that are set in the questions.

I found making test based on my SA's philosophy to be more interesting and gives the students a better opportunity to demonstrate their understanding. However this method works the best when students are given the chance of doing a retest or some sort of opportunity to improve their mark. My SA gave students the opportunity to do a second unit test with the ability of starting only doing questions based on sections that they were not able to complete. For example if students got a C+ on their first test they would only have to do the B and A level questions. I only had students do one unit test, however I did allow students to do a retest based on the above method in order for students to understand their growth.

While I enjoyed writing my tests using the above method I followed a more traditional method on making test for chemistry, focused on giving students a number to show students if they got an answer right or not. For example my unit test for the Mole Unit assigned numbers to each questions. However I followed the same method on writing questions for the unit test for chemistry as I did when I wrote questions for the unit test for math. Most of my questions asked students to think through the information given to come up with the answers and some asked them to describe the process they would go through to make a solution with a specific concentration or how to convert between different units.

Saturday, 17 June 2017

Changes to My Lesson Plan

Before the start of the practicum my lessons were focused entirely on one big idea and one activity related to the big idea. An example of this would be my first lesson plan for my statistics unit for Foundation of Math 11. While this isn't necessarily a bad way to plan a lesson it does require a good sense of timing and pacing of the lesson, something that I did not learn just yet. Another problem with the lesson and activity was that there was too much busy work when it came to doing the activity. The handout that was given to the students required them to calculate the average value of the PISA scores of 40 different countries, as well as the median and mode of the data set. Doing these calculations with only a calculator would be time consuming and repetitive. Reflecting back on this lesson it appears to me that the handout was meant to only waste the students time and to eat up the 75 minutes of class time. Because of this this left little time for the main thrust of the lesson/activity which was looking at the differences between the mean, median, and mode and what they are used for.

As the practicum went along my lessons focused more around completing a handout for that one lesson, with additional practice from the textbook or from another handout for that lesson. I still designed it the handout based on one big idea for that lesson but I included a far greater variety of questions for the student to do. I'm going to use a handout that I used when teaching my students how to factor quadratic functions. The handout flowed a lot more naturally than the handout for statistics. A review question is given to the students at the start before moving on with the big idea of the lesson, factoring a quadratic function. I included boxes for the students in order to teach them the area method of factoring out a quadratic function, with the first example being done as a class. The first question is also the easier of the four, with each question introducing something new to factoring out functions. The second question have students figuring out the factored form of a function if a does not equal to 1. The third question have students figuring out the factored form of a function when some of the constants aren't positive numbers before finishing the handout off with a word problem that requires them to think through more carefully about what the question is asking them to do. I also included practice problems from the textbook for students to practice and work on when they were done with the handout.

Looking at these two handout for two different lessons I see several areas of growth from when I started my practicum to where I eventually found myself near the end of it. While still focusing on one general big idea and one activity I ended utilizing multiple manageable questions for students to do during the class. Rather than having them do the same calculations over and over again my questions in the second handout where varied and introduced different elements for students to consider. By doing this I was able to get to the main point of the lesson more effectively to my students then before. The second handout also gave students a review activity for them to refresh what they learned previously before applying that knowledge to the new material. There is also a more natural flow in the second handout than in the first. Rather than jumping directly into the new content a review activity is used to start off the lesson, followed by an example questions and multiple questions in increasing difficulty before ending it with more practice questions for the students to do. This makes it a lot more organized, clear, and easier to follow along. The first handout seemed daunting, despite the relatively simple calculation needed, as it jumped straight into the students doing questions, having them to use a large set of numbers, and having no context or review activity for them to do beforehand.

Monday, 19 December 2016

Sunday, 11 December 2016

Proofs And How to Show Them

In university proofs is one of the more common ways of showing mathematical concepts, showing how they work, why they are true, and why they work and can be used in other mathematical proofs. Learning to prove mathematical concepts is then useful to learn during high school as it can provide a needed challenge for students who want a harder challenge or possibly spark an interest in math for some students by showing them why the theorem is true.

On Wednesday we observed two ways of doing proofs, one through deductive reasoning and another using an app to demonstrate to students that something is true. The deductive approach is a more traditional approach to solving proofs in which the theorem is proven by working through it logically and using other theorems to help prove the theorem for every possible case. While this approach is very interesting to see and can be very convincing if explained properly it is a very abstract approach as well. Since the aim is to prove the theorem for every single case variables are used instead of numbers which could get very confusing for some people. As such doing proofs through deduction could prove the theorem to yourself but it could be difficult to prove it to a friend or skeptic, especially if either of them aren't used to seeing math in more abstract terms. Another way we investigated for solving proofs is by using an application called "Geogebra". This can easily show that a theorem works (example all angles in a right triangle equals to 180 degrees) by showing examples in which the theorem is true. However it may convince a sceptic or a friend, as they get to see the theorem being applied and working, it may not convince yourself as there could be cases in which the theorem may not work. So individually both methods to proving something may not convince a student, depending on how engaged they are with learning about mathematics, but combining the two can probably convince more students then if done separately. Showing the students examples of the theorem working before explaining the proof of the theorem allows students to see how it works as well as why it works.