Dave Hewitt describes that math can be taught as a series of arbitrary terms or methods, or as something that can be memorized (what's the procedure to solve this question?) or each mathematical ideas can be taught as something that is necessary to learn before being able to move on to something more difficult. An example of what would be arbitrary in a math lesson would be telling students that the acronym SOH CAH TOA simply means sin(θ) = opposite/hypotenuse, cos(θ) = adjacent/hypotenuse, and tan(θ) = opposite/adjacent. Necessary would then be having students figure out that that is what the acronyms represent or being aware of the relationship between the sides of the right triangle with the angle of the triangle. This would be similar to Richard Skemp's article on Relational and Instrumental understanding, with relational understanding is knowing how and why to do something (necessary), and instrumental understanding is remembering how to do it (arbitrary).
Similar to teaching for relational and instrumental understanding to students, there needs to be a balance when teaching what is necessary and arbitrary in math to students. While ideally it would be good for all students to be aware what is necessary to move on in math some students work better if they remember the arbitrary in math. As such when teaching math to students it is a good idea to strike a balance between the two. Give enough information to the students so that they can solve the questions on their own using basic "facts" (arbitrary) but having it so that students can work out the harder questions on their own by being aware of similar patterns to other things that they have solved before (necessary). As such it is important to note that math should not be exclusively you or the teacher explaining every single step to the students. Leave enough material as a mystery for them so that they can work it out on their own.
Thanks Tommy. I think you've understood what Hewitt means by 'arbitrary', but I think his meaning of 'necessary' is different from what you've written here. 'Necessary' for Hewitt means something that is logically necessary -- i.e., something that a learner could figure out by using reasoning -- not what is necessary in order to move ahead with the curriculum. It's a subtle but important difference! We'll work with these ideas in class tomorrow.
ReplyDelete