We got asked two puzzles to answer. Well they’re are more like answers to questions, but having to work your way back in order to get to a start is an important way of thinking that we don’t tend to focus on too much. We tend to focus on how to get answers rather than how the answers came to be, if that makes any sense or difference.
For puzzle 1 the question I would probably write it as would be: “A fiddler, his wife, and their child, a piper, ate 5 whole cakes and a quater of a cake. How did they share it equally amongst themselves?” The way the puzzle was worded seems to suggests that the food was divided evenly among the fiddler, his wife, the piper, and his mother. That seems to be a lot of math that have to be done in order to divide the original three whole cakes amongst the four of them (They would get around ¾ of a cake if anyone was wondering). It would much easier then to assume that two of the people preset in the original puzzle are in fact the same person. As such I’ve made it so that the piper is the son of the fiddler and his wife. I chose the wife and the mother to be the same person only because it would make some sense for a husband and wife to also have a child with them and share their cake with him/her. Also I like to the poetic nature of having the child wanting to be a musician just like his father.
For puzzle 2 I would probably word the question like: “My only friend was that man’s son. My father only knew that man because he was his godfather. Do I have any siblings?” Since I have a large family with multiple siblings I could only make assumptions of what it was like to not have any siblings. I assume that having not siblings would get pretty lonley and the way the puzzle was worded the narrator seems to know the man somewhat well. At least well enough to know the relationship between the man’s father and the narrator’s father. From that I just thought of different ways how one can be considered someone’s son without (presumbly) having any blood relation with that person. I choose godfather/godson only because that seems to be the more simplistic answer. Another relationship I considered was between a man and his father figure. While I like the idea this seems more complicated to explain or justify for two people to consider one another as father and son enough for the narrator to consider that as being the two’s relationship.
I formed these questions based on what I felt to be the most realistic or simplistic reasoning to justify the wording of the puzzles. I based them mostly on my own biases and how I assumed what my life would be like on the other side. As such we should expect the students answer to be very different from one another if this was done in a classroom.
Very interesting, Tommy! I am especially intrigued by your rewording of the second puzzle. For the cake question, I think they each ate 1 3/4 cakes...!
ReplyDelete