Here is the links to the statistics unit plan and first three lesson of the unit.
Statistics Unit Plan
Lesson 1
Lesson 2
Lesson 3
Monday, 19 December 2016
Sunday, 11 December 2016
Proofs And How to Show Them
In university proofs is one of the more common ways of showing mathematical concepts, showing how they work, why they are true, and why they work and can be used in other mathematical proofs. Learning to prove mathematical concepts is then useful to learn during high school as it can provide a needed challenge for students who want a harder challenge or possibly spark an interest in math for some students by showing them why the theorem is true.
On Wednesday we observed two ways of doing proofs, one through deductive reasoning and another using an app to demonstrate to students that something is true. The deductive approach is a more traditional approach to solving proofs in which the theorem is proven by working through it logically and using other theorems to help prove the theorem for every possible case. While this approach is very interesting to see and can be very convincing if explained properly it is a very abstract approach as well. Since the aim is to prove the theorem for every single case variables are used instead of numbers which could get very confusing for some people. As such doing proofs through deduction could prove the theorem to yourself but it could be difficult to prove it to a friend or skeptic, especially if either of them aren't used to seeing math in more abstract terms. Another way we investigated for solving proofs is by using an application called "Geogebra". This can easily show that a theorem works (example all angles in a right triangle equals to 180 degrees) by showing examples in which the theorem is true. However it may convince a sceptic or a friend, as they get to see the theorem being applied and working, it may not convince yourself as there could be cases in which the theorem may not work. So individually both methods to proving something may not convince a student, depending on how engaged they are with learning about mathematics, but combining the two can probably convince more students then if done separately. Showing the students examples of the theorem working before explaining the proof of the theorem allows students to see how it works as well as why it works.
On Wednesday we observed two ways of doing proofs, one through deductive reasoning and another using an app to demonstrate to students that something is true. The deductive approach is a more traditional approach to solving proofs in which the theorem is proven by working through it logically and using other theorems to help prove the theorem for every possible case. While this approach is very interesting to see and can be very convincing if explained properly it is a very abstract approach as well. Since the aim is to prove the theorem for every single case variables are used instead of numbers which could get very confusing for some people. As such doing proofs through deduction could prove the theorem to yourself but it could be difficult to prove it to a friend or skeptic, especially if either of them aren't used to seeing math in more abstract terms. Another way we investigated for solving proofs is by using an application called "Geogebra". This can easily show that a theorem works (example all angles in a right triangle equals to 180 degrees) by showing examples in which the theorem is true. However it may convince a sceptic or a friend, as they get to see the theorem being applied and working, it may not convince yourself as there could be cases in which the theorem may not work. So individually both methods to proving something may not convince a student, depending on how engaged they are with learning about mathematics, but combining the two can probably convince more students then if done separately. Showing the students examples of the theorem working before explaining the proof of the theorem allows students to see how it works as well as why it works.
Sunday, 4 December 2016
Math Fair Thoughts
During the SNAP math fair on Wednesday at the Museum of Anthropology the most interesting thing I noticed was how different each math puzzles was even among similar puzzles. There was one puzzle that I saw twice during the math fair that involved playing a game with your partner in which you have to remove the game pieces in a 9 x 5 board by removing multiple entire rows or columns. The two puzzles differentiated by the win state (one had the winner being the last person to pick up the last piece while the other had the loser being the last person to pick up the last piece). What was more interesting was how both groups presented their puzzles/game, with one being about canoes and the other being bottle caps.
It was obvious by how the students would explain their solutions and how excited they were when we solve their puzzles that the students knew their puzzles well and what kind of hints would be useful in solving the puzzles. The students were able to become expert with their puzzles and was obviously enthused in explaining it to others. It could be useful as such to do something similar with our students during the practicum by making them work on a puzzle of their choice or make and modifying it so that it can be either easier or harder to solve and putting their own personal spin to how to resent the puzzle.
The most common problems that I found were that some of the explanation of the rules of the puzzles could get confusing quickly. While it was clear that most of the students understood the rules of their puzzles well it would have been an interesting extension to the math fair if the students were able to create a simpler set of rules in solving the puzzles. While the students were able to simplify the math for the puzzles it would have made it interesting if the students had simplified the rules of the puzzles as well.
It was obvious by how the students would explain their solutions and how excited they were when we solve their puzzles that the students knew their puzzles well and what kind of hints would be useful in solving the puzzles. The students were able to become expert with their puzzles and was obviously enthused in explaining it to others. It could be useful as such to do something similar with our students during the practicum by making them work on a puzzle of their choice or make and modifying it so that it can be either easier or harder to solve and putting their own personal spin to how to resent the puzzle.
The most common problems that I found were that some of the explanation of the rules of the puzzles could get confusing quickly. While it was clear that most of the students understood the rules of their puzzles well it would have been an interesting extension to the math fair if the students were able to create a simpler set of rules in solving the puzzles. While the students were able to simplify the math for the puzzles it would have made it interesting if the students had simplified the rules of the puzzles as well.
SNAP Math Fair
I would definitely attempt to do a SNAP Math Fair or a something similar during my practicum. It is a really good idea to try to attempt to engage students with math and fits into the focus on inquiry in the new curriculum. The SNAP Math Fair encourages the students to figure out their own answers to the questions and how to change the question in order for them to personalize the questions. But the problem is how to attract students who are not interested in math into doing the math fair instead of it being full of students who are already interested and good in math. One way to do this is probably to start off small with one or two math class. Students can work on a project near the end of a unit and have a gallery walk in which students can walk and see what their peers tried to do with their project. The project can be anything from puzzles that demonstrates the materials that they learned in the unit or presenting something interesting that relates to the unit in some way. The build up to the math fair can be modified further by allowing students to look up their own puzzles rather than having students modify and solve a series of suggested questions.
Sunday, 27 November 2016
Maththatmatters and Teaching For Social Justice
I think the idea of mathematics being neutral is not a very true statement. Mathematics is a tool that can be used to push an agenda with companies using mathematics such as statistics or optimization tools to help with their marketing and turning a larger profit. Governments can use statistical datas that are collected from census in order to push for more projects that can benefit the economy or environment, or sometimes creating projects that can hurt the environment. So mathematics can't be neutral to social or environmental justice causes because it can be used to justify pushing for or against social and environmental justice causes. I think David Stocker realize how important math is in deciding these changes in society and the environment but also knows that the common view of mathematics is "why should I care?" I think this is a great thing to try to teach as it can be easily assumed by students that the math involved would be extremely difficult but from the excerpt from the book shows a lot of it is math that can be done by students by the end of the early grade math classes.
Reading the excerpt of the book does make me think of ways to incorporate questions or a lesson that involves overpopulation as well as further questions that can be added on to the lesson that were shown in the excerpt. For example for the lesson "If Syrup Costs 2 Cents A Cup..." it would be a good idea to include guiding questions such as "Why is it that marketing take such a large cut from sale prices?" or "Why does the factory take a small cut? Why would a company benefit from a factory taking a smaller cut?" I think that all topics in math can be viewed through a social justice and environmental justice lens but at the same time simpler mathematic topics such as measurements and algebra can be more easily approached through and social and environmental justice lens then more abstract topics like calculus if only because the leap from math to social justice is much smaller. Sometimes it's easy to forget that you're trying to find the area underneath a function when trying to integrate it.
Reading the excerpt of the book does make me think of ways to incorporate questions or a lesson that involves overpopulation as well as further questions that can be added on to the lesson that were shown in the excerpt. For example for the lesson "If Syrup Costs 2 Cents A Cup..." it would be a good idea to include guiding questions such as "Why is it that marketing take such a large cut from sale prices?" or "Why does the factory take a small cut? Why would a company benefit from a factory taking a smaller cut?" I think that all topics in math can be viewed through a social justice and environmental justice lens but at the same time simpler mathematic topics such as measurements and algebra can be more easily approached through and social and environmental justice lens then more abstract topics like calculus if only because the leap from math to social justice is much smaller. Sometimes it's easy to forget that you're trying to find the area underneath a function when trying to integrate it.
Tuesday, 22 November 2016
A Baker's Secret?
According to Eugenia Cheng the basic cake recipe has to have
all the basic ingredients be equal in their weights to one another. But before
that what do we consider basic ingredients for making a cake? Doing a quick
google search we get an answer for what looks like an easy plain yellow cake containing flour, salt, butter, eggs, vanilla, baking powder, sugar, and milk.
I’m not much of a baker but I would categorized a basic cake as something that
is edible, but not entirely flavourful. As such ingredients such as sugar, salt
and vanilla would be something I would not think of as basic ingredients for a
basic cake as they are generally used to give flavour for cakes. All the other
ingredients could be substituted or be left out but the cake would look
significantly different if they weren’t included. As such the basic ingredients
that we need to look for are flour, baking powder, butter, eggs, and milk.
The first recipe I found was for a simple white cake
containing ½ cups of butter, 2 eggs, ½ cups of milk, 1 ½ cups of flour, and 1 ¾
teaspoons of baking powder. This website allows me to convert cups to gram conversion, while it might
not be the most accurate but I think it can give us a good estimate for some of
the ingredients. Using this table we get:
- ½ cups of butter = 113 g
- 1 ½ cups of flour = 192 g
- The density of milk is 1.035 g/mL. 1 cup is around 236.588 mL. ½ cup of milk will then be 118.294 mL which would weight about 122.434 g.
- Using this conversion website we get 1 ¾ cups of baking powder equaling to about 8.05 g.
- A large size egg weighs around 56-63 g. As such two eggs should weigh around 112-126 g.
The second recipe for a basic yellow cake had 3 cups of
flour, 2 ½ teaspoons of baking powder, 2/3 cups of butter, 2 eggs, and 1 ¼ cups
of milk. Using the same method as before we get 384 g of flour, 156 g of
butter, 11.5 g baking powder, 112-126 g of eggs, and 306.086 g of milk.
The third recipe for a vanilla cake uses 1 ½ cup of flour, 1
½ teaspoon of baking powder, ½ cups of butter, 2 large eggs, and ½ cup of
milks. This would be equivalent to 192 g
of flour, 6.90 g of baking powder, 113 g of butter, 112-126 g of eggs, and 122.434
g of milk.
For the most part all the weights of the basic ingredients seem to be the same for the exception of baking powder. This is probably because using too much baking powder can potentially ruin the cake as it is used a the rising agent during the baking process. The cake would rise too much and contain mostly air in it, possibly burning the cake easily.
Sunday, 20 November 2016
Arbitrary and Necessary
Dave Hewitt describes that math can be taught as a series of arbitrary terms or methods, or as something that can be memorized (what's the procedure to solve this question?) or each mathematical ideas can be taught as something that is necessary to learn before being able to move on to something more difficult. An example of what would be arbitrary in a math lesson would be telling students that the acronym SOH CAH TOA simply means sin(θ) = opposite/hypotenuse, cos(θ) = adjacent/hypotenuse, and tan(θ) = opposite/adjacent. Necessary would then be having students figure out that that is what the acronyms represent or being aware of the relationship between the sides of the right triangle with the angle of the triangle. This would be similar to Richard Skemp's article on Relational and Instrumental understanding, with relational understanding is knowing how and why to do something (necessary), and instrumental understanding is remembering how to do it (arbitrary).
Similar to teaching for relational and instrumental understanding to students, there needs to be a balance when teaching what is necessary and arbitrary in math to students. While ideally it would be good for all students to be aware what is necessary to move on in math some students work better if they remember the arbitrary in math. As such when teaching math to students it is a good idea to strike a balance between the two. Give enough information to the students so that they can solve the questions on their own using basic "facts" (arbitrary) but having it so that students can work out the harder questions on their own by being aware of similar patterns to other things that they have solved before (necessary). As such it is important to note that math should not be exclusively you or the teacher explaining every single step to the students. Leave enough material as a mystery for them so that they can work it out on their own.
Similar to teaching for relational and instrumental understanding to students, there needs to be a balance when teaching what is necessary and arbitrary in math to students. While ideally it would be good for all students to be aware what is necessary to move on in math some students work better if they remember the arbitrary in math. As such when teaching math to students it is a good idea to strike a balance between the two. Give enough information to the students so that they can solve the questions on their own using basic "facts" (arbitrary) but having it so that students can work out the harder questions on their own by being aware of similar patterns to other things that they have solved before (necessary). As such it is important to note that math should not be exclusively you or the teacher explaining every single step to the students. Leave enough material as a mystery for them so that they can work it out on their own.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)